Bombertalk

5. Monfries
4. Lloyd
3. Hille
2. Welsh
1. Reimers

Apologies to: Fletch, McVeigh, Stanton, Watson, Myers

I strongly disagree - and despite my name I am not one of the people clamoring McVeigh captain, McVeigh Captain all the time (see above) David Hille is a good player but I believe that Mark McVeigh has much more of the personal qualities that make a good leader - at least it's my impression not that...

5. Hille
4. Lloyd
3. Welsh
2. Lonergan
1. Reimers

and plenty of unlucky ones: Stanton, McVeigh, Watson, McPhee,...

Clever pun, however I am a big fan of Spike too - obviously - and I can tell you that bagging Essendon Players of the class of Matthew Lloyd particularly when he is struggling a bit would not go well with Mark. One of the reasons he is a top bloke. I would be thrilled to have Mark captain Essendon b...

Thanks for the feedback everyone. I've been to three different shops now checking stuff out (and getting more info than my poor old brain could handle) and I'm now tending towards a plasma. I'm keen on a Pioneer so if anyone has one, or can relate info about them, I'd appreciate it. Pioneer is defi...

While I thought we had quite a few good players this time I am a bit at a loss to decide who was best. I will give 5. to Andrew Welsh who is often criticized, was not listed in the best by the club, and sacrificed his own stats to keep Mitchell absolutely quiet. Good effort. 4. Houli - amazing versa...

5. Fletch
4. McPhee
3. Winderlich
4. Lonergan
5. Reimers

Just missed : Lovett, Houli

Personlly I would have gone with "A Midfielder! a midfielder!, my membership for a Midfielder" or "Now is the winter of our discontent, made glorious summer by this first round draft pick" or "Alas poor Knighta, we didnt get to know him well !!" Windy_Hill thus wins BT...

5/ McVeigh
4/ Welsh
3/ Hislop
2/ Reimers
1/ Stanton

Agree. Stanton needs to toughen up and to improve his disposal ; no question.

GET THAT #5 OFF YOUR BACK. Yes guys, you guessed it, it's a critical thread about Stanton. Im stunned that people gave him as our best player. Sure he had 25 touches, but at 60% effeciency, what does that tell you? He had a direct hand in three of Collingwoods first 4 goals, with stupid handballs t...

Our defense will be fine. The game will be won or lost in the midfield.

3. Houli
2. Hille
1. Ryder

5. Dustin Fletcher
4. Mark McVeigh (for three quarters!)
3. Brent Stanton (best game this year)
2. David Hille
1. Paddy Ryder

and quite a few others had a good game - damn injuries

Anyone know if he's still signing contracts on a yearly basis? It's time to secure him up with the new teams coming in. As we know, Spike loves a surf... :wink: Some legends die hard, the last time Mark took a one year contract was in 2003. He signed for two years in 2004 and again for two year in ...

The captaincy really suited him. Played with great leadership, and is just a quality player. Shame about the injury because he would have got his 3rd BOG. Now he will miss a month :evil: Not sure how much longer Lloyd is going to keep the captaincy, but I hope Macca gets it next. Spot on Winning a ...

115

5. McVeigh
4. Ryder
3. Lovett
2. McPhee
1. Hille

I finally watched the game. Depressing, but we will recover next week.
anyway.
3. Ryder
2. Davey
1. Mal

I really do not understand the AFL "management" they seem to consistently achieve the contrary of their stated goal. Vlad seems to be the George Bush of sport. They are worried about the lack of attractiveness of the "umpire" position to the general population. You would like to ...