MH_Bomber wrote: ↑Wed Oct 12, 2022 7:18 pm
What I can’t understand is when he’s been given a run he’s not been bad.
This year the selected Melbourne forward line didn’t function that well. Brown et al were holding him out but how well did they play in retrospect?
It seems all to be about confidence. When dropped he lost confidence and didn’t help him.
Commentators have been quite critical of him this year. He doesn't chase when a forward entry is repulsed and he doesn't gut run to lead over half the time.
Who knows - maybe he can take the hint and change.
MH_Bomber wrote: ↑Wed Oct 12, 2022 3:37 pm
We got the Weiderman!!
I think it's a good thing.
Can't quite understand Melbourne on him.
Weideman is 2 things.
1 - a taller Waterman. In and out of the team. Has no defensive pressure. Either kicks 4 goals or does zero.
2 - a wake-up call to Harrison Jones that he's not cutting it as a tall forward option.
MH_Bomber wrote: ↑Wed Oct 12, 2022 7:18 pm
What I can’t understand is when he’s been given a run he’s not been bad.
This year the selected Melbourne forward line didn’t function that well. Brown et al were holding him out but how well did they play in retrospect?
It seems all to be about confidence. When dropped he lost confidence and didn’t help him.
Commentators have been quite critical of him this year. He doesn't chase when a forward entry is repulsed and he doesn't gut run to lead over half the time.
Who knows - maybe he can take the hint and change.
He Bloody Well Better!Not the way to welcome a new Chum(and Welcome all the same),but Everyone on the Playing List,especially those already with us,need to Pull your Fingers Out your Collective Arse,because Brutally Speaking -
MH_Bomber wrote: ↑Wed Oct 12, 2022 7:18 pm
What I can’t understand is when he’s been given a run he’s not been bad.
This year the selected Melbourne forward line didn’t function that well. Brown et al were holding him out but how well did they play in retrospect?
It seems all to be about confidence. When dropped he lost confidence and didn’t help him.
Commentators have been quite critical of him this year. He doesn't chase when a forward entry is repulsed and he doesn't gut run to lead over half the time.
Who knows - maybe he can take the hint and change.
He Bloody Well Better!Not the way to welcome a new Chum(and Welcome all the same),but Everyone on the Playing List,especially those already with us,need to Pull your Fingers Out your Collective Arse,because Brutally Speaking -
YOU HAVE ACHIEVED NOTHING!!!!!!!!!!
I think this is a little OTT. Should allow him to settle in and give it a red hot go. He’s behind the pecking order at Demonski. He’ll be a focal point here.
It’s a bit like a housing assembly in a car engine bay. Lots of components compacted in a tight space. Each has a role to play in getting the vehicle moving. Throw a spanner in the works snd it’ll upset the mechanics.
BenDoolan wrote: ↑Mon Oct 10, 2022 1:33 pm
Will Setterfield and pick #68 to EFC for a future 4th round
great, getting carltons dregs.
Getting him for nothing
hes taking a spot on the list. wasnt good enough at gws albeit had some injury problems. chose carlton over us and now has been squeezed out of their best 22. so now we get him??
ill be happy to be proved wrong but just because he was a high draft pick means nothing after so many years. same goes for weideman. melbourne despetately needed a kp forward to stand up last season and mcdonald went down with a season ending injury. weideman still couldnt get a regular spot in their 22.
