Gumby or Carlisle?

filthy2 · Post by **filthy2** » Thu Dec 15, 2011 1:17 pm

First some assumptions.

a) Gumbleton gets finally as fit as and has a fair run at it. Carlisle puts on a bit more tone and muscle (his Old Man is built like a brick shithouse).

b) The "Brainstrust" is looking at either of them for CHF or FF, assuming Fletch, Tayte, Hooker play tall with Hibberd and Hardy playing medium and whomever small and Dyson heads to the wing or midfield. Hurls can play either.

On revealed form, who gets your vote for the gig.

Me its Carlisle. Great mark (buckets), sound body and a much better kick. Gumby's kicks even in the 2's was awful; holding it and dropping too high and rarely holds it over the kicking leg. Up and under hospital balls. Can't afford poor disposals these days.

Thoughts.

Rossoneri · Post by **Rossoneri** » Thu Dec 15, 2011 2:10 pm

Carlisle.

You can't ignore the fact that Gumby won't be right in 2012. He is still in alot of pain and I would be stunned if he plays next season.

He really does need to eat though.

Post by **Jazz_84** » Thu Dec 15, 2011 3:22 pm

Carlisle hands down, even if Gumby got himself right i think Carlisle is more versatile and simply a better suited footballer to the current game

little_ripper · Post by **little_ripper** » Thu Dec 15, 2011 3:26 pm

they play both of them?

Rossoneri · Post by **Rossoneri** » Thu Dec 15, 2011 3:29 pm

little_ripper wrote:they play both of them?

No room

If you have Fletch, Pears and Hooker down back with Hurley, Crameri and the resting ruckman forward, you can't then play both Gumby and Carlisle.

I'd be more inclined to play Carlisle as he can play back as well.

swoodley · Post by **swoodley** » Thu Dec 15, 2011 3:32 pm

It's a no brainer...Carlisle is streets ahead of Gumby, even if Gumby was fully fit.

j-mac31 · Post by **j-mac31** » Thu Dec 15, 2011 4:41 pm

Carlsile.

Gumbleton needs to play 8-10 VFL games without a sissy injury before being considered.

robrulz5 · Post by **robrulz5** » Thu Dec 15, 2011 4:52 pm

Carlisle. He is a better footballer.

Windy_Hill · Post by **Windy_Hill** » Thu Dec 15, 2011 5:00 pm

Havent seen either of them at their best so its a moot point

Lets make the decision when we know what we are dealing with.

Sorry to be difficult Filth

bomberdonnie · Post by **bomberdonnie** » Thu Dec 15, 2011 8:09 pm

Gumby is dead

BenDoolan · Post by **BenDoolan** » Thu Dec 15, 2011 8:20 pm

bomberdonnie wrote:Gumby is dead

Weekend at Gumby's....

bomberdonnie · Post by **bomberdonnie** » Thu Dec 15, 2011 8:57 pm

BenDoolan wrote:
bomberdonnie wrote:Gumby is dead
Weekend at Gumby's....

Who?

Windy_Hill · Post by **Windy_Hill** » Thu Dec 15, 2011 10:42 pm

bomberdonnie wrote:Gumby is dead

F111 · Post by **F111** » Thu Dec 15, 2011 11:22 pm

I hope Gumbleton has a great year, and shows enough to stay and progress. I have no doubt Carlisle will.

GoalSneak · Post by **GoalSneak** » Fri Dec 16, 2011 12:26 pm

Carlisle - no contest. He has the makings of a very, very high class CHF.

j-mac31 · Post by **j-mac31** » Fri Dec 16, 2011 4:30 pm

bomberdonnie wrote:
BenDoolan wrote:
bomberdonnie wrote:Gumby is dead
Weekend at Gumby's....
Who?

You can't name him in one post and then ask "who?" Conflicting jokes. Sue me.

Windy_Hill · Post by **Windy_Hill** » Fri Dec 16, 2011 5:22 pm

Wouldnt it be great if they could both add something to the team. Competition for places cant hurt

I just have a feeling Gumby has been given as much time as possible because the coaches genuinely feel he can be a player.

Apart from his kicking, he has shown he can be a pretty solid tall forward - and remember, he has only played 22 games and probably most of those have been with injury or the fear of injury holding him back.

nomolos · Post by **nomolos** » Sat Dec 17, 2011 12:53 pm

Carlisle > Gumbleton

Ive said this elsewhere a million times

j-mac31 · Post by **j-mac31** » Sat Dec 17, 2011 5:02 pm

Windy_Hill wrote:I just have a feeling Gumby has been given as much time as possible because the coaches genuinely feel he can be a player.

No doubt, but with the emergence of Carlisle, I couldn't give a flying f*** anymore whether Gumbleton makes it or not. Even last year I didn't care.

BenDoolan · Post by **BenDoolan** » Sat Dec 17, 2011 7:41 pm

Well, in the words from a former club champion in 2008 (passed on 3rd hand) - Gumbleton is no good and will not make it.

Bombertalk

Gumby or Carlisle?

Gumby or Carlisle?

Re: Gumby or Carlisle?

Re: Gumby or Carlisle?

Re: Gumby or Carlisle?

Re: Gumby or Carlisle?

Re: Gumby or Carlisle?

Re: Gumby or Carlisle?

Re: Gumby or Carlisle?

Re: Gumby or Carlisle?

Re: Gumby or Carlisle?

Re: Gumby or Carlisle?

Re: Gumby or Carlisle?

Re: Gumby or Carlisle?

Re: Gumby or Carlisle?

Re: Gumby or Carlisle?

Re: Gumby or Carlisle?

Re: Gumby or Carlisle?

Re: Gumby or Carlisle?

Re: Gumby or Carlisle?

Re: Gumby or Carlisle?