Carlisle

BenDoolan · Post by **BenDoolan** » Tue Sep 08, 2015 3:51 pm

I hope he does go to Carlton. He can f****** rot there for the rest of his career. Don't care what we get for him, just f*** off.

paddyl90 · Post by **paddyl90** » Tue Sep 08, 2015 3:56 pm

BenDoolan wrote:I hope he does go to Carlton. He can f****** rot there for the rest of his career. Don't care what we get for him, just f*** off.

This.

Flip · Post by **Flip** » Tue Sep 08, 2015 3:58 pm

rockhole wrote:
Flip wrote:F**king gutless, Judas......hope the other blokes just ostracise him 100%.

3 Years and a 190, 196 and 200cm walk.....charming.
Which begs the question, if we beat the charges in November, on top of everything else, we would have lost 3 key position players for next to f*** all.

Has any sporting team world wide ever been so victimised as EFC.??

Plus 4 first and second round draft picks collectively, a massive fine decided 5 days after THAT presser, missing the Finals, losing our Coach to a Witches of Salem Inquisition type of thing.

Just imagine it..."Oh WADA said you're OK ......sorry about that guys....sorry about bringing your Club and name to your knees"

Post by **boncer34** » Tue Sep 08, 2015 4:06 pm

FWIW why are we so upset at Carlisle leaving?

The blokes been offered a better contract elsewhere, so what?

Any of you in here gonna knock back and extra year and a couple of hundred thousand more if a competitor comes knocking for your services?

s'dreams · Post by **s'dreams** » Tue Sep 08, 2015 4:07 pm

If we don't get a good deal during trade week ... time to seek compensation from the AFL ... if krueser is worth an early draft pick (15 brownlow votes over 119 games and 8 seasons) ... compared to CArsisle (AA once, 12 Brownlow votes in 6 seasons and 85 games).

And I do think its in the AFL's interests to put a stop to this walking for no reimbursement - otherwise their free agency rules just look plain dumb.

Special pick please.

kelvin_sheedy · Post by **kelvin_sheedy** » Tue Sep 08, 2015 4:09 pm

The club is tracking beautifully will all the clean air about.

No coach. No gun CHB. No f****** leadership.
No chance in trade week.
We may be the first club a draftee refuses to play for and sits out the year.

s'dreams · Post by **s'dreams** » Tue Sep 08, 2015 4:24 pm

kelvin_sheedy wrote: We may be the first club a draftee refuses to play for and sits out the year.

Has already happened.... Tim Watson at Freo?

DC2 · Post by **DC2** » Tue Sep 08, 2015 4:25 pm

s'dreams wrote:If we don't get a good deal during trade week ... time to seek compensation from the AFL ... if krueser is worth an early draft pick (15 brownlow votes over 119 games and 8 seasons) ... compared to CArsisle (AA once, 12 Brownlow votes in 6 seasons and 85 games).

And I do think its in the AFL's interests to put a stop to this walking for no reimbursement - otherwise their free agency rules just look plain dumb.

Special pick please.

carlisle was never AA.

auditor · Post by **auditor** » Tue Sep 08, 2015 4:26 pm

Trade home for a set of used retreads at least we'd get some traction out of them!

DC2 · Post by **DC2** » Tue Sep 08, 2015 4:29 pm

Plus if they are paying him 750k good luck to them . he is not worth that.

Hooker looked good up front, but with carlisle gone he must move back to defense. We need TBC to regain form so he and Mckernan can rest in the square and have JD at chf.

Post by **boncer34** » Tue Sep 08, 2015 4:33 pm

s'dreams wrote:
kelvin_sheedy wrote: We may be the first club a draftee refuses to play for and sits out the year.
Has already happened.... Tim Watson at Freo?

West Coast

gringo · Post by **gringo** » Tue Sep 08, 2015 4:42 pm

boncer34 wrote:FWIW why are we so upset at Carlisle leaving?

The blokes been offered a better contract elsewhere, so what?

Any of you in here gonna knock back and extra year and a couple of hundred thousand more if a competitor comes knocking for your services?

I couldn't agree more. He owes EFC nothing. If anything, he has a right to be annoyed with the club for have a show cause notice slapped on him.

Windy_Hill · Post by **Windy_Hill** » Tue Sep 08, 2015 4:47 pm

boncer34 wrote:FWIW why are we so upset at Carlisle leaving?

The blokes been offered a better contract elsewhere, so what?

Any of you in here gonna knock back and extra year and a couple of hundred thousand more if a competitor comes knocking for your services?

I don't give a rat's clacker that he's leaving

I care about what we get in return

MH_Bomber · Post by **MH_Bomber** » Tue Sep 08, 2015 6:03 pm

The truth is he may have bucket hands but he is slow as a wet week and a massive sook. I dont see him as a great loss. Pears looked better on Sunday than he has played all year. Lets reinvigorate Tate and not worry about this disloyal prick.

Goodbye.

Gimps · Post by **Gimps** » Tue Sep 08, 2015 6:34 pm

MH_Bomber wrote:The truth is he may have bucket hands but he is slow as a wet week and a massive sook. I dont see him as a great loss. Pears looked better on Sunday than he has played all year. Lets reinvigorate Tate and not worry about this disloyal prick.

Goodbye.

Let's not forget he was underdone for the latter part of the season and playing in a team that wasn't really putting in 100%

s'dreams · Post by **s'dreams** » Tue Sep 08, 2015 8:50 pm

boncer34 wrote:
s'dreams wrote:
kelvin_sheedy wrote: We may be the first club a draftee refuses to play for and sits out the year.
Has already happened.... Tim Watson at Freo?
West Coast

I'm in fine form today!

s'dreams · Post by **s'dreams** » Tue Sep 08, 2015 8:52 pm

DC2 wrote:
s'dreams wrote:If we don't get a good deal during trade week ... time to seek compensation from the AFL ... if krueser is worth an early draft pick (15 brownlow votes over 119 games and 8 seasons) ... compared to CArsisle (AA once, 12 Brownlow votes in 6 seasons and 85 games).

And I do think its in the AFL's interests to put a stop to this walking for no reimbursement - otherwise their free agency rules just look plain dumb.

Special pick please.
carlisle was never AA.

All Aberfeldie??? Whoops

According to the RAge, Carsisle wants the club to get fair compensation and has ruled out doing a McPhee in the pre-season draft.

One can only hope.

bpdons · Post by **bpdons** » Tue Sep 08, 2015 9:44 pm

I'm filthy that he wants to go elsewhere. It's his choice, not ours though.

He had genuine talent, just needed to get his head right - was pretty clear he was disinterested at times in 2015. But when he was in position in the backline, he was fantastic for us.

I hold no anger towards him, and I wish him well in his endeavours - but I really hope he doesn't waste his talent at Carlton.

Windy_Hill · Post by **Windy_Hill** » Tue Sep 08, 2015 11:28 pm

s'dreams wrote:
DC2 wrote:
s'dreams wrote:If we don't get a good deal during trade week ... time to seek compensation from the AFL ... if krueser is worth an early draft pick (15 brownlow votes over 119 games and 8 seasons) ... compared to CArsisle (AA once, 12 Brownlow votes in 6 seasons and 85 games).

And I do think its in the AFL's interests to put a stop to this walking for no reimbursement - otherwise their free agency rules just look plain dumb.

Special pick please.
carlisle was never AA.
All Aberfeldie??? Whoops

According to the RAge, Carsisle wants the club to get fair compensation and has ruled out doing a McPhee in the pre-season draft.

One can only hope.

Of course he's going to say that.

He's also going to claim that Carlton's 3rd pick is "fair compensation "

Windy_Hill · Post by **Windy_Hill** » Tue Sep 08, 2015 11:30 pm

Who's taking bets on a bile ridden feature from Caro in the next 24 hours claiming how Carlisle is fleeing the toxic legacy of James Hird?

Bombertalk

Carlisle

Re: Carlisle

Re: Carlisle

Re: Carlisle

Re: Carlisle

Re: Carlisle

Re: Carlisle

Re: Carlisle

Re: Carlisle

Re: Carlisle

Re: Carlisle

Re: Carlisle

Re: Carlisle

Re: Carlisle

Re: Carlisle

Re: Carlisle

Re: Carlisle

Re: Carlisle

Re: Carlisle

Re: Carlisle

Re: Carlisle