The Worst Call You Have Ever Made on Bombertalk

[BERT]

I thought Shane Harvey was going to be a gun.

I also thought Jay Neagle would be a very good player for us. I liked him as I backed him for first goal a few times and won.

I was sort of pissed off we drafted Hurley and didn't draft Yarran. That was probably my worst one.

[bomberdonnie]

I said that we shouldn't draft Cyril Rioli as we had an abundance of quality in that area

[Jazz_84]

I said that we shouldn't draft Cyril Rioli as we had an abundance of quality in that area

think this is the winner so far

[Mrs Mercuri]

I said that we shouldn't draft Cyril Rioli as we had an abundance of quality in that area

I suppose Davey was playing rather well at the time........ but yeh thats a pretty bad one!!!!

We certainly need to draft a small crumbing forward at some stage this year!!

[Megan]

I said that we shouldn't draft Cyril Rioli as we had an abundance of quality in that area

DUDE.

I really thought Lalich had potential. But that's cause he is Tasmanian.

I also always had faith that Ces would be all that as a ruckman... and once a year he was

[Jazz_84]

everytime we played Sydney i thought finally Bolton has arrived, sign him up for 5 years

[bomberdonnie]

I said that we shouldn't draft Cyril Rioli as we had an abundance of quality in that area

DUDE.

I really thought Lalich had potential. But that's cause he is Tasmanian.

I also always had faith that Ces would be all that as a ruckman... and once a year he was

I really don't think Juddster was from Tassie? Could be wrong

[bomberdonnie]

I know I wasn't the only one with Cyril 'fess up!!!

[rockhole]

I was sure that Nash was going to be the next Watson and that Cupes would be another Ablett. I once said I enjoyed going to Victoria Park until I got my head kicked in after Tuddy flattened some Filth moron right in front of the Collinwood members and I cheered.

I thought that Atkinson was the best thing since sliced bread and that Johns was the new messiah. Tend to be from the glass half full school but can still make some shocking calls. All in the spirit of things I guess.

I love these Mea Culpa threads!!

[Crazyman]

Thinking at the start of last year that we were a strong chance to make the finals after an ok showing the year before...

[BenDoolan]

I once said Angus Monfries was going to be a star.

[swoodley]

I said that we shouldn't draft Cyril Rioli as we had an abundance of quality in that area

DUDE.

I really thought Lalich had potential. But that's cause he is Tasmanian.

I also always had faith that Ces would be all that as a ruckman... and once a year he was

I really don't think Juddster was from Tassie? Could be wrong

He was originally from WA

[Western Red]

Being from WA - I kept backing Bradley in - then I saw him play on ANZAC day and realised he was a spud of the highest order..

[Megan]

No you're quite right, I got Lalich confuzzled with that other star of the time, McAlister. Who I didn't have a massive amount of faith in.

[BenDoolan]

No you're quite right, I got Lalich confuzzled with that other star of the time, McAlister. Who I didn't have a massive amount of faith in.

McAlister was New Zealandish

[dodgey]

remember telling my brother in law once that the ONLY reason Gary Ablett jnr gets a game is because of his name and he was overrated ..

On the bomber front I tend to be very reserved in my judgement..

[BERT]

remember telling my brother in law once that the ONLY reason Gary Ablett jnr gets a game is because of his name and he was overrated ..

On the bomber front I tend to be very reserved in my judgement..

I know someone that played TAC cup against Ablett and he said the only reason he got drafted was because of his name. He is a massive Geelong supporter as well.

[robrulz5]

remember telling my brother in law once that the ONLY reason Gary Ablett jnr gets a game is because of his name and he was overrated ..

On the bomber front I tend to be very reserved in my judgement..

I know someone that played TAC cup against Ablett and he said the only reason he got drafted was because of his name. He is a massive Geelong supporter as well.

Probably wasn't that bad a call at the time as he was a lazy forward pocket player at first. You would have never known he was going to turn into an absolute gun.

[j-mac31]

Yep ... 2005 delisting ... never knew the reason why (though I can suspect ... but with Cupido, Zantuck etc around at the time he wouldn't have been Robinson Caruso)

Is he the brother of the CSI Miami guy?

[j-mac31]

not sure if i actually stated it or not on BT but back in 2004 i said that Adam McPhee and Nick Rewoildt will progress together in ability over their careers

My uncle did the same. If he (and you) weren't white, I'd say "racist".

Also my uncle said Scott Lucas was too slow to be any good.