Posted: Wed May 16, 2007 11:05 pm
Well you better get a sense of humour as its likely to be the biggest football story of the yearnathanskinner wrote:
P.S The fact people are discussing Sheedys replacement at this stage is a joke.
The great forum in name of the Essendon Football Club
http://bombertalk4.com/
Well you better get a sense of humour as its likely to be the biggest football story of the yearnathanskinner wrote:
P.S The fact people are discussing Sheedys replacement at this stage is a joke.
Why the hell did we want Kevin Sheedy in 1981 when we could have got Allan Jeans or John Nicholls (both premiership coaches)? The club punted on an untried Kevin Sheedy and look what he did. Some people's "logic" about certain individuals amazes me.....nathanskinner wrote:why the hell would we want daniher? A talented list without a win this season. You cant entirely blame injuries, they lost their first couple with an entire team. Also other clubs have done it tough and got a win.
His re-signing? I'm of the opposite thought Windy. I'm confident he'll be around.Windy_Hill wrote:Well you better get a sense of humour as its likely to be the biggest football story of the yearnathanskinner wrote:
P.S The fact people are discussing Sheedys replacement at this stage is a joke.
Yeah, wouldn't mind taking a punt on Vossy. He's smart, super-competitive, and from the article seems to already have a natural talent for player management. Give him two or three years in the job and he'll be fantastic, with the bonus of being young and fit enough to handle the enormous pressure of that job.tom9779 wrote:if sheeds has had enough.
http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/news/v ... 36208.html
then in no doubt this man should be our next senior coach.
Daniher is not untried. He coaches the Melbourne Football Club, who have had less wins then us this season with a list of players that are expected to make finals. Why get him?BenDoolan wrote:Why the hell did we want Kevin Sheedy in 1981 when we could have got Allan Jeans or John Nicholls (both premiership coaches)? The club punted on an untried Kevin Sheedy and look what he did. Some people's "logic" about certain individuals amazes me.....nathanskinner wrote:why the hell would we want daniher? A talented list without a win this season. You cant entirely blame injuries, they lost their first couple with an entire team. Also other clubs have done it tough and got a win.
They have been missing their top 3 or 4 players.nathanskinner wrote:Daniher is not untried. He coaches the Melbourne Football Club, who have had less wins then us this season with a list of players that are expected to make finals. Why get him?BenDoolan wrote:Why the hell did we want Kevin Sheedy in 1981 when we could have got Allan Jeans or John Nicholls (both premiership coaches)? The club punted on an untried Kevin Sheedy and look what he did. Some people's "logic" about certain individuals amazes me.....nathanskinner wrote:why the hell would we want daniher? A talented list without a win this season. You cant entirely blame injuries, they lost their first couple with an entire team. Also other clubs have done it tough and got a win.
The question I asked is why did the EFC employ Kevin Sheedy ahead of two proven premiership coaches? Using tunnel visioned logic would suggest that Allan Jeans or John Nicholls were better candidates. You seem lost in the fact that Neale Daniher has got the Melbourne Football Club into a Grand Final - only one of two coaches who have done so in 43 years. He must be a dud eh? If it were not for the juggernaut that was the EFC in 2000, Neale Daniher would be a premiership coach.nathanskinner wrote:Daniher is not untried. He coaches the Melbourne Football Club, who have had less wins then us this season with a list of players that are expected to make finals. Why get him?BenDoolan wrote:Why the hell did we want Kevin Sheedy in 1981 when we could have got Allan Jeans or John Nicholls (both premiership coaches)? The club punted on an untried Kevin Sheedy and look what he did. Some people's "logic" about certain individuals amazes me.....nathanskinner wrote:why the hell would we want daniher? A talented list without a win this season. You cant entirely blame injuries, they lost their first couple with an entire team. Also other clubs have done it tough and got a win.
I'll give you the benefit of the doubt for not understanding. I said, when the EFC had a decision to make back in 1981, they had a choice between proven premiership coaches in Allan Jeans and John Nicholls. Using tunnel vision logic (of some in here), the club should have chosen either of them over Sheeds. This is not my opinion. I used the argument against someone trying to discredit Neale Daniher with this logic...Rover 7 wrote:Anyone questioning Sheedy's original appointment must have Spaghetti for brains.
Jeans,Nicholls????Nien,never.
Understand?why the hell would we want daniher? A talented list without a win this season. You cant entirely blame injuries, they lost their first couple with an entire team. Also other clubs have done it tough and got a win.
Were coming off a 15th placed finish last year, matched our wins already at this stage of the year and were complaining, imagine demon supporters. They would have to be very filthy.
P.S The fact people are discussing Sheedys replacement at this stage is a joke.
I'll let you know once you tell me who Vintage is.....Rover 7 wrote:You're not Vintage in disguise are you?