Votes V Adelaide

[Sismis]

The fact that McPhee is getting votes shows how average we were tonight.

Yes he kicked 4 goals. 3 of them were gimmies. He cost us 6 goals (at least) which were caused directly from his turnovers, his dropped marks, his getting pinged for running 15 metres in a circle , or not going hard enough at contests.

Absolutely 100% must be traded while we can get something for him. His lack of skill (ordinary kick, ordinary mark) and his brain-dead decision making has cost us about 3 goals a game, every week, for about 5 years.

I'm sure some of you don't agree, and this was not intended to be a criticism of anyone who gave him votes (seriously). Sorry for the rant.

5. Hocking
4. Lovett-Murray
3. Welsh
2. Dyson
1. Fletcher

You are kidding arent you? 4 goals in a team that was universally spanked. He is a valuable player, I just don't think he should
be playing in defence.

[j-mac31]

I've already forgotten although I seem to remember thinking Fletcher was probably our best.