Re: Gumby or Carlisle?
Posted: Mon Dec 19, 2011 1:29 pm
Will be stunned if he plays 8 games this year and kicks more than 2 in any of them.
The great forum in name of the Essendon Football Club
http://bombertalk4.com/
Will do gimperGimps wrote:Get rid of that bloody avatar Windy..
Much better. Thanks mate.Windy_Hill wrote:Will do gimperGimps wrote:Get rid of that bloody avatar Windy..
What's the point. We know now.Windy_Hill wrote: We will know by September 2012 - lets bookmark this for then
Bullshite....we know only what has transpired. The future doesnt have to be the same as the past grasshopper.ZeroEffect wrote:What's the point. We know now.Windy_Hill wrote: We will know by September 2012 - lets bookmark this for then
Somehow you have missed the point completelyWindy_Hill wrote:Bullshite....we know only what has transpired. The future doesnt have to be the same as the past grasshopper.ZeroEffect wrote:What's the point. We know now.Windy_Hill wrote: We will know by September 2012 - lets bookmark this for then
Truuuuuuuuuust me he is max gawnWindy_Hill wrote:Bomberdonnie....all I am saying is hope springs eternal. As George Michael so eloquently stated..."You Gotta Have Faith"
Unless what?Rossoneri wrote:Gumby will be delisted at years end unless he has an amazing season where he cements himself in the best 22.
bomberdonnie wrote:Unless what?Rossoneri wrote:Gumby will be delisted at years end unless he has an amazing season where he cements himself in the best 22.
So Rosso, lets say he plays 8-10 games and shows enough to suggest that he could be a player - not superstar stuff, but perhaps the sort of signs of potential that the new "wunderkind" Jake Carlisle has shown - delist or keep?Rossoneri wrote:bomberdonnie wrote:Unless what?Rossoneri wrote:Gumby will be delisted at years end unless he has an amazing season where he cements himself in the best 22.![]()
He needs to have a really really good season, like that you would expect for a bloke who has been on the list for 6 years and not necessarily one that has only played 22 games.
For me to keep, I would like him to show a bit more. Playing 8-10 games is not showing enough. If he plays 16 games and kicks 40-odd goals, then I would keep.Windy_Hill wrote:So Rosso, lets say he plays 8-10 games and shows enough to suggest that he could be a player - not superstar stuff, but perhaps the sort of signs of potential that the new "wunderkind" Jake Carlisle has shown - delist or keep?Rossoneri wrote:bomberdonnie wrote:Unless what?Rossoneri wrote:Gumby will be delisted at years end unless he has an amazing season where he cements himself in the best 22.![]()
He needs to have a really really good season, like that you would expect for a bloke who has been on the list for 6 years and not necessarily one that has only played 22 games.
Insurance - although point taken.....he's probably forced our premiums up single handedlyWindy Hille wrote:How much has Gumby cost the club in medical bills? I reckon they could pay off the new facility twice over if they didn't select this physical catastrophe.
I'd say one. He didn't deserve to play in 1993, was a stupid call.Windy_Hill wrote:Insurance - although point taken.....he's probably forced our premiums up single handedlyWindy Hille wrote:How much has Gumby cost the club in medical bills? I reckon they could pay off the new facility twice over if they didn't select this physical catastrophe.
Look, it took Dean Wallis about 10 years or more to play his 100th game...the guy couldnt take a trick with injuries but eventually, he wqas a valuable contributor to 2 Premierships
Wow, it's all making sense now. Wallis would have to be one of the worst players in history to get to 100 games let alone win 2 flags.Windy_Hill wrote:Insurance - although point taken.....he's probably forced our premiums up single handedlyWindy Hille wrote:How much has Gumby cost the club in medical bills? I reckon they could pay off the new facility twice over if they didn't select this physical catastrophe.
Look, it took Dean Wallis about 10 years or more to play his 100th game...the guy couldnt take a trick with injuries but eventually, he wqas a valuable contributor to 2 Premierships
George also has anonymous sex in public toilets and parks.Windy_Hill wrote:As George Michael so eloquently stated..."You Gotta Have Faith"