Lloydy REPORTED!
Makes you wonder.
I mean Andrew Welsh makes head high contact, something the AFL made a big song and dance about stamping out, cops one week which is downgraded reprimand.
Leo Barry smacks Cameron Ling in the head while he had it over the ball and doesn't even get f****** sited.
Lloyd reacts to a bullshit cheap shot from Carrol and gets offered a week, while Carrol does not even get looked at.
Bloody joke.
Thought this system was meant to stamp out the inconsistencies involved with the old system. Bring back the old system I say, hell of a lot more consistent than this bullshite match review panel crap.
Well done Anderson and Demetriou, you stole a system that works well in the NRL and royally f***** it up you stupid knob jockeys.
I mean Andrew Welsh makes head high contact, something the AFL made a big song and dance about stamping out, cops one week which is downgraded reprimand.
Leo Barry smacks Cameron Ling in the head while he had it over the ball and doesn't even get f****** sited.
Lloyd reacts to a bullshit cheap shot from Carrol and gets offered a week, while Carrol does not even get looked at.
Bloody joke.
Thought this system was meant to stamp out the inconsistencies involved with the old system. Bring back the old system I say, hell of a lot more consistent than this bullshite match review panel crap.
Well done Anderson and Demetriou, you stole a system that works well in the NRL and royally f***** it up you stupid knob jockeys.
"The panel looked at contact between Hawthorn's Campbell Brown and Collingwood's Dane Swan from the fourth quarter of Sunday's game but due to the video evidence was inconclusive"
that was thrown out..... i heard there isn't any video footage of lloydy's incident either?? has to be thrown out in that case, just has to be, if its not then i suspect serious conspiracy
that was thrown out..... i heard there isn't any video footage of lloydy's incident either?? has to be thrown out in that case, just has to be, if its not then i suspect serious conspiracy
- jimmyc1985
- Champion of Essendon
- Posts: 5869
- Joined: Wed Aug 30, 2006 11:33 pm
- Location: Position A
Footage of the Lloyd incident below. Make up your own minds:
http://video2.foxsports.com.au/video.ph ... 52&id=3429
http://video2.foxsports.com.au/video.ph ... 52&id=3429
They have footage. He'll get the week. I think we have no chance of getting him off.
It was assessed as low contact (lowest standard) body contact (lowest standard) and intentional. We can't get him off on that - it was clearly intentional.
Only chance we can get him off is if we can convince the Melb bloke to testify that he took a dive. Only chance.
It was assessed as low contact (lowest standard) body contact (lowest standard) and intentional. We can't get him off on that - it was clearly intentional.
Only chance we can get him off is if we can convince the Melb bloke to testify that he took a dive. Only chance.
- jimmyc1985
- Champion of Essendon
- Posts: 5869
- Joined: Wed Aug 30, 2006 11:33 pm
- Location: Position A
Tasmanian Dams case could also be argued.Staggy wrote:They have footage. He'll get the week. I think we have no chance of getting him off.
It was assessed as low contact (lowest standard) body contact (lowest standard) and intentional. We can't get him off on that - it was clearly intentional.
Only chance we can get him off is if we can convince the Melb bloke to testify that he took a dive. Only chance.
Pfffft. As if.jimmyc1985 wrote:Tasmanian Dams case could also be argued.Staggy wrote:They have footage. He'll get the week. I think we have no chance of getting him off.
It was assessed as low contact (lowest standard) body contact (lowest standard) and intentional. We can't get him off on that - it was clearly intentional.
Only chance we can get him off is if we can convince the Melb bloke to testify that he took a dive. Only chance.
Donoghue vs Stevenson, all the way....
does this take forever for anyone else???jimmyc1985 wrote:Footage of the Lloyd incident below. Make up your own minds:
http://video2.foxsports.com.au/video.ph ... 52&id=3429
-
- On the Rookie List
- Posts: 227
- Joined: Mon Sep 11, 2006 1:14 pm
-
- Top Up Player
- Posts: 22
- Joined: Sat Jun 23, 2007 10:01 pm
I don't think it is simply a case of deliberately running into a player, this occurs quite often in varying degrees- he has to intentionally "charge".Staggy wrote:That's true, they will try, but the reality is that he charged straight at the bloke. Not in the course of play, just randomly. Its intentional.dom_105 wrote:They will try and get it downgraded to reckless.
That will get him under the 100 points.
Didak admitted that he deliberately ran into the back of Haselby but he was completely exonerated.
Oh and I'm quoting R v Crabbe.
-
- High Draft Pick
- Posts: 734
- Joined: Wed Aug 30, 2006 9:13 pm
- Location: Under cover, deep in the heart of Carlscum territory
Didn't work for me, hopefully on Bomber TV though. Do the MRP members have high security dwellings, if you get my drift. fair dinkum basketball here we come.Jazz_84 wrote:does this take forever for anyone else???jimmyc1985 wrote:Footage of the Lloyd incident below. Make up your own minds:
http://video2.foxsports.com.au/video.ph ... 52&id=3429
Was Lloyd reported by an Umpire, or the MRP? I have heard conflicting statements.
If it was the umpire who reported him, I was always under the impression that an umpire had to tell the player that he was reporting him before the start of the next quarter. I know from my limited knowledge of local football, plenty of cases have been thrown out as the result of umpires informing the player after the start of the next quarter that they were indeed reported.
Just something to think about.
If it was the umpire who reported him, I was always under the impression that an umpire had to tell the player that he was reporting him before the start of the next quarter. I know from my limited knowledge of local football, plenty of cases have been thrown out as the result of umpires informing the player after the start of the next quarter that they were indeed reported.
Just something to think about.