Jake Carlisle

[DYSON#2]

must be blooded, starting against collingwood. that is all

[Scott]

Asked the question in another thread. We had nothing to lose tonight by playing this kid, we have unearthed something special in Hardingham, we should be looking at this kid as well.

[Windy_Hill]

Asked the question in another thread. We had nothing to lose tonight by playing this kid, we have unearthed something special in Hardingham, we should be looking at this kid as well.

I thought he was injured?

[BenDoolan]

Well, I agree Mr Dyson.

The cue is definitley back in the rack so you may as well see how guys like Carlisle, Anthony Long and Marigliani go at AFL level.

Don't bother with Slattery H, Welsh, Quinn, Prismall, Neagle et al for the rest of the season.

But none of this will happen.

[Mrs Mercuri]

If Carlisle backs up last weeks performance for Bendigo today then Im sure his name will definately come up for selection again next week.

[GoalSneak]

Carlisle is very underdeveloped physically but looks a really good prospect for next year. I wouldn't play him against Collingwood, it would destroy his confidence if not his body, but would give him a try against Brisbane. Lovett-Murray at CHF against Collingwood for mine, should have been played there last night.

[Mrs Mercuri]

Carlisle is very underdeveloped physically but looks a really good prospect for next year. I wouldn't play him against Collingwood, it would destroy his confidence if not his body, but would give him a try against Brisbane. Lovett-Murray at CHF against Collingwood for mine, should have been played there last night.

Yay someone else that thinks that Natrat is dangerous on the forward line.... has kicked bags of 4 goals a few times in his career and can take a nice mark!!

Carlisle is super skinny (like most of the young guys on our list it seems) so maybe the match against the Lions would be a better outing for him!!

[GoalSneak]

Carlisle is very underdeveloped physically but looks a really good prospect for next year. I wouldn't play him against Collingwood, it would destroy his confidence if not his body, but would give him a try against Brisbane. Lovett-Murray at CHF against Collingwood for mine, should have been played there last night.

Yay someone else that thinks that Natrat is dangerous on the forward line.... has kicked bags of 4 goals a few times in his career and can take a nice mark!!

Carlisle is super skinny (like most of the young guys on our list it seems) so maybe the match against the Lions would be a better outing for him!!

Lovett-Murray is a forward (preferably a flanker but could fill in in a key position) who can pinch hit on the wing or in defence if really, really desperate. Successive Essendon coaches have not realised this to his detriment and ours.

[j-mac31]

May as well play him and despite being very skinny he won't be thrown around by the Collingwood defenders - because the ball won't be near him.

[lozza89]

Carlisle is very underdeveloped physically but looks a really good prospect for next year. I wouldn't play him against Collingwood, it would destroy his confidence if not his body, but would give him a try against Brisbane. Lovett-Murray at CHF against Collingwood for mine, should have been played there last night.

Yay someone else that thinks that Natrat is dangerous on the forward line.... has kicked bags of 4 goals a few times in his career and can take a nice mark!!

Carlisle is super skinny (like most of the young guys on our list it seems) so maybe the match against the Lions would be a better outing for him!!

I have always thought NLM was dangerous up forward. He can mark, and he does have a physical presence when he is on the field. Wouldn't mind him out of the goal square actually