Where are we really at?
Where are we really at?
This is the 2006 WC Premiership XVIII:
B: Adam Selwood Darren Glass David Wirrpanda
HB: Brett Jones Adam Hunter Beau Waters
C: Michael Braun Ben Cousins Andrew Embley
HF: Daniel Chick Ashley Hansen Tyson Stenglein
F: Chad Fletcher Quinten Lynch Rowan Jones
Foll: Dean Cox Chris Judd Daniel Kerr
How many '07 Dons, in their usual position, get into this team?
For me:
3 Definite starters:
Lloyd - FF for Lynch
Lucas - CHF for Hansen
Hird - HFF for Stenglein
4 Challenging for spots:
Fletcher / Mal - Glass (FB)... Both are great but Glass can play - jury out on Fletch as CHB and Hunter goes alright).
Mcphee - Jones (HBF)... Not on last season's form, though.
McVeigh - Selwood (BP)
Maybe we're not as good as we look on the training track... What thinks everyone else? We've got the spine but have we really improved enough in other areas?
B: Adam Selwood Darren Glass David Wirrpanda
HB: Brett Jones Adam Hunter Beau Waters
C: Michael Braun Ben Cousins Andrew Embley
HF: Daniel Chick Ashley Hansen Tyson Stenglein
F: Chad Fletcher Quinten Lynch Rowan Jones
Foll: Dean Cox Chris Judd Daniel Kerr
How many '07 Dons, in their usual position, get into this team?
For me:
3 Definite starters:
Lloyd - FF for Lynch
Lucas - CHF for Hansen
Hird - HFF for Stenglein
4 Challenging for spots:
Fletcher / Mal - Glass (FB)... Both are great but Glass can play - jury out on Fletch as CHB and Hunter goes alright).
Mcphee - Jones (HBF)... Not on last season's form, though.
McVeigh - Selwood (BP)
Maybe we're not as good as we look on the training track... What thinks everyone else? We've got the spine but have we really improved enough in other areas?
There isn't a team in the AFL who would currently be thinking they will struggle to make the eight this year. And why wouldn't they? Everyone's fresh after the Christmas break, fit, looking forward to the year ahead. Supporters are pumped up, no longer thinking of the long, cold winter days spent watching their team being bent into compromising positions by teams from all points of the country the previous year…
As you rightly pointed out though, realistically we have three players who would walk into the West Coast team, and arguably another five or so that would be pressing for positions.
My major concern is that none of these players come from our midfield. We are still slow, unskilled, weak and inexperienced through the middle, and whilst these problems can be worked on during the off-season, we are not suddenly going to see JJ, Pev, Watson or Kepler come out and consistently hit targets by foot or chase down quick players.
I don't think we are really going to know how we'll go this year until we see what sort of improvement our younger, quicker and more skilled midfielders have made. Our spine is big bossin, but unless we see alarming amounts of improvement from the likes of Winderlich, Dyson, Nash, Watson, Dempsey, McPhee etc, we are going to struggle again.
As you rightly pointed out though, realistically we have three players who would walk into the West Coast team, and arguably another five or so that would be pressing for positions.
My major concern is that none of these players come from our midfield. We are still slow, unskilled, weak and inexperienced through the middle, and whilst these problems can be worked on during the off-season, we are not suddenly going to see JJ, Pev, Watson or Kepler come out and consistently hit targets by foot or chase down quick players.
I don't think we are really going to know how we'll go this year until we see what sort of improvement our younger, quicker and more skilled midfielders have made. Our spine is big bossin, but unless we see alarming amounts of improvement from the likes of Winderlich, Dyson, Nash, Watson, Dempsey, McPhee etc, we are going to struggle again.
But that doesn't really mean our midfield is that bad when they can't get into the WCE side. I mean how many midfielders would you take ahead of:
Cousins, Judd, Kerr, Braun and Embley
I can think of dal santo, luke power and even those two wouldn't really replace anyone except possibly Braun or Embley, but they are more on par rather than streaks ahead. Braun is very very underrated due to the players his has around him I believe. So in saying that the fact our players can't break into that midfield isn't as bad as it seems, because no body can break into that midfield.
Cousins, Judd, Kerr, Braun and Embley
I can think of dal santo, luke power and even those two wouldn't really replace anyone except possibly Braun or Embley, but they are more on par rather than streaks ahead. Braun is very very underrated due to the players his has around him I believe. So in saying that the fact our players can't break into that midfield isn't as bad as it seems, because no body can break into that midfield.
spot on Gatsid, no team would stack up comparing midfields to WC, and while it is good to have great individual stars, lets not forget the second best team last year are not a team of champions, but a champion team, that is what we need to emulate.
48.2 sismis to ZRS, SIX, ???!!! Its coming towards the commentary box Im leaving!!!
48.3 sismis to ZRS, FOUR, Who needs Bradman when weve got ZRS
48.4 sismis to ZRS, FOUR, Brillian cover drive by ZRS
48.6 sismis to ZRS, SIX, Display of Raw power and brutality by ZRS
48.3 sismis to ZRS, FOUR, Who needs Bradman when weve got ZRS
48.4 sismis to ZRS, FOUR, Brillian cover drive by ZRS
48.6 sismis to ZRS, SIX, Display of Raw power and brutality by ZRS
- Windy_Hill
- Champion of Essendon
- Posts: 12859
- Joined: Thu Aug 31, 2006 10:23 pm
- bomberdonnie
- Champion of Essendon
- Posts: 8575
- Joined: Sun Sep 03, 2006 7:25 pm
- Location: Old Hobart Town
I think in modern footy its about how good the best 18 you can get on the park are and how fit they are when they're out there. At the moment, against WC, we win 3 positions, hold our own in about 4 or 5 and lose the rest (10/11). That's rarely going to mean a win.Windy_Hill wrote:Someone on this forum keeps saying its not about how good your best 10 player are but rather your worse 10.
We need to correct that balance - and I can't wait to see how our younger guys (i.e. Stants, Monfreeeeze, CJ, Hille, Laycock, NLM, Welsh, Watson, Keps and Lovett) are ready to take the next step in this competition and become genuine stars. That will be the difference between challenging for mediocrity and challenging for a premiership.
That's true. WC have an amazing midfield. However, the players I mentioned - Winderlich, Dyson, Nash, Watson, Dempsey, JJ, Pev, Watson or Kepler - are going to struggle (with the possible exception of JJ) to get a run in any teams midfield.Gatsid wrote:But that doesn't really mean our midfield is that bad when they can't get into the WCE side. I mean how many midfielders would you take ahead of:
Cousins, Judd, Kerr, Braun and Embley
I can think of dal santo, luke power and even those two wouldn't really replace anyone except possibly Braun or Embley, but they are more on par rather than streaks ahead. Braun is very very underrated due to the players his has around him I believe. So in saying that the fact our players can't break into that midfield isn't as bad as it seems, because no body can break into that midfield.
That I can agree with, and I see your point. I thought you were saying that if we can't take one spot in that midfield then your midfield was crap and I was like hang on a minute thats a pretty damn hard midfield to crack intogringo wrote:That's true. WC have an amazing midfield. However, the players I mentioned - Winderlich, Dyson, Nash, Watson, Dempsey, JJ, Pev, Watson or Kepler - are going to struggle (with the possible exception of JJ) to get a run in any teams midfield.Gatsid wrote:But that doesn't really mean our midfield is that bad when they can't get into the WCE side. I mean how many midfielders would you take ahead of:
Cousins, Judd, Kerr, Braun and Embley
I can think of dal santo, luke power and even those two wouldn't really replace anyone except possibly Braun or Embley, but they are more on par rather than streaks ahead. Braun is very very underrated due to the players his has around him I believe. So in saying that the fact our players can't break into that midfield isn't as bad as it seems, because no body can break into that midfield.
![Razz :P](./images/smilies/icon_razz.gif)
- Windy_Hill
- Champion of Essendon
- Posts: 12859
- Joined: Thu Aug 31, 2006 10:23 pm
I have been saying it for as long as I can remember. If Bolton, Pev and Heff are in our best 22, then we will finish last. If however they are nothign more than depth players, as in fill positions 25-28, then we will be in with a shot of the 8.Windy_Hill wrote:Someone on this forum keeps saying its not about how good your best 10 player are but rather your worse 10.
He kicks on the left
He kicks on the riiiiiiiiigggggggggggghhhhhhhhhhttttttttttttt
That boy Hurley
Makes Riewoldt look shite!
He kicks on the riiiiiiiiigggggggggggghhhhhhhhhhttttttttttttt
That boy Hurley
Makes Riewoldt look shite!