Round 10...vs GWS Giants

[BenDoolan]

Out: T. Bellchambers, M. Gleeson, A. Francis, D. Zaharakis, T. Cutler, B. Ham, M. Redman, J. Stewart, J. Townsend

In: K. Langford, J. Daniher, D. Clarke, M. Guelfi, C. McKenna, S. McKernan, I. Mosquito, J. Begley

[s'dreams]

Out: T. Bellchambers, M. Gleeson, A. Francis, D. Zaharakis, T. Cutler, B. Ham, M. Redman, J. Stewart, J. Townsend

In: K. Langford, J. Daniher, D. Clarke, M. Guelfi, C. McKenna, S. McKernan, I. Mosquito, J. Begley

Cahill needs a rest as well. Time for Clarke to come back as a tagger

[grassy1]

Think I’ll tip AWFULL’s Baby here.

[BenDoolan]

Out: T. Bellchambers, M. Gleeson, A. Francis, D. Zaharakis, T. Cutler, B. Ham, M. Redman, J. Stewart, J. Townsend

In: K. Langford, J. Daniher, D. Clarke, M. Guelfi, C. McKenna, S. McKernan, I. Mosquito, J. Begley

Cahill needs a rest as well. Time for Clarke to come back as a tagger

But surely they’ll give him the next 150 games to see if he can prove himself?

[nudder12]

Out: T. Bellchambers, M. Gleeson, A. Francis, D. Zaharakis, T. Cutler, B. Ham, M. Redman, J. Stewart, J. Townsend

In: K. Langford, J. Daniher, D. Clarke, M. Guelfi, C. McKenna, S. McKernan, I. Mosquito, J. Begley

Agree with this. None of those "outs" are taking us anywhere. Should have kept Mitch Brown. People said he wasn't going to be in our next Premiership team, but jeebus he still earnt his spot before any of that lot.
Ins??
Right now I can't be bothered remembering who's injured etc, let's just get as many games as we can into anyone who hasn't already had a go.
Get Daniher & Mosquito in. Yeah, they said Draper wasn't 100% ready but he did OK, so let's do the same for these 2.
And anyone else that isn't injured.
Just do it.

[Windy_Hill]

I think Ham and Redman have something to offer. Redman was a gun last year...another player simply going backwards. Ham has some real dash but needs time.

The rest can just GAGF

[nudder12]

I think Ham and Redman have something to offer. Redman was a gun last year...another player simply going backwards. Ham has some real dash but needs time.

The rest can just GAGF

Redman maybe.
Ham - it's a no from me. Too many limitations. Plenty out there that can run as he does, but also offer some strength in a contest, take an overhead mark (or at least spoil) and can do some time in the midfield. He's just too small. If he was Caleb Daniel, that might be a different story.

[BenDoolan]

I think Ham and Redman have something to offer. Redman was a gun last year...another player simply going backwards. Ham has some real dash but needs time.

The rest can just GAGF

I like the Red Dog. But he’s in ordinary form. Did a good thing last week, but has had his pants pulled down quite a few times this year. To be fair, I don’t think he was the right match up for Cameron at all. Saad should have been in him.

[DC2]

I think Ham and Redman have something to offer. Redman was a gun last year...another player simply going backwards. Ham has some real dash but needs time.

The rest can just GAGF

I like the Red Dog. But he’s in ordinary form. Did a good thing last week, but has had his pants pulled down quite a few times this year. To be fair, I don’t think he was the right match up for Cameron at all. Saad should have been in him.

LOL, as soon as i saw redman manning up on cameron i knew it was going to be a long night. Not sure whose bright idea that was. Guess they didnt want to have saad tied done to charlie so we could use his run. We need another quality small defender thats for sure.

James Stewart is horrible. Yes he's missed a lot of football, but he was doing nothing even before the injuries. Would have been better to play smack as the KPF even though smack has been terrible this year too. We have no tall marking options. Sad to say it, but our best option maybe to try draper playing deep forward to give us some sort of target. This midget forward line just isnt cutting it. Langford should be played forward too.

[s'dreams]

I think Ham and Redman have something to offer. Redman was a gun last year...another player simply going backwards. Ham has some real dash but needs time.

The rest can just GAGF

I like the Red Dog. But he’s in ordinary form. Did a good thing last week, but has had his pants pulled down quite a few times this year. To be fair, I don’t think he was the right match up for Cameron at all. Saad should have been in him.

LOL, as soon as i saw redman manning up on cameron i knew it was going to be a long night. Not sure whose bright idea that was. Guess they didnt want to have saad tied done to charlie so we could use his run. We need another quality small defender thats for sure.

James Stewart is horrible. Yes he's missed a lot of football, but he was doing nothing even before the injuries. Would have been better to play smack as the KPF even though smack has been terrible this year too. We have no tall marking options. Sad to say it, but our best option maybe to try draper playing deep forward to give us some sort of target. This midget forward line just isnt cutting it. Langford should be played forward too.

OK - but whose brilliant idea was it to play TBell forward? That must have cause much mirth among the Brisbane defenders.

[grassy1]

Well,that’s The Pest gone for next week.

Greene’s done a Hammy!

[nudder12]

Out: T. Bellchambers, M. Gleeson, A. Francis, D. Zaharakis, T. Cutler, B. Ham, M. Redman, J. Stewart, J. Townsend

In: K. Langford, J. Daniher, D. Clarke, M. Guelfi, C. McKenna, S. McKernan, I. Mosquito, J. Begley

Agree with this. None of those "outs" are taking us anywhere. Should have kept Mitch Brown. People said he wasn't going to be in our next Premiership team, but jeebus he still earnt his spot before any of that lot.
Ins??
Right now I can't be bothered remembering who's injured etc, let's just get as many games as we can into anyone who hasn't already had a go.
Get Daniher & Mosquito in. Yeah, they said Draper wasn't 100% ready but he did OK, so let's do the same for these 2.
And anyone else that isn't injured.
Just do it.

Just realised...9 Outs above and only 8 Ins.
So I'm adding Mutch to the Ins list.

[Windy_Hill]

Out: T. Bellchambers, M. Gleeson, A. Francis, D. Zaharakis, T. Cutler, B. Ham, M. Redman, J. Stewart, J. Townsend

In: K. Langford, J. Daniher, D. Clarke, M. Guelfi, C. McKenna, S. McKernan, I. Mosquito, J. Begley

Agree with this. None of those "outs" are taking us anywhere. Should have kept Mitch Brown. People said he wasn't going to be in our next Premiership team, but jeebus he still earnt his spot before any of that lot.
Ins??
Right now I can't be bothered remembering who's injured etc, let's just get as many games as we can into anyone who hasn't already had a go.
Get Daniher & Mosquito in. Yeah, they said Draper wasn't 100% ready but he did OK, so let's do the same for these 2.
And anyone else that isn't injured.
Just do it.

Just realised...9 Outs above and only 8 Ins.
So I'm adding Mutch to the Ins list.

Surely we give Stewart one more game to break down in??

[s'dreams]

Out: T. Bellchambers, M. Gleeson, A. Francis, D. Zaharakis, T. Cutler, B. Ham, M. Redman, J. Stewart, J. Townsend

In: K. Langford, J. Daniher, D. Clarke, M. Guelfi, C. McKenna, S. McKernan, I. Mosquito, J. Begley

Agree with this. None of those "outs" are taking us anywhere. Should have kept Mitch Brown. People said he wasn't going to be in our next Premiership team, but jeebus he still earnt his spot before any of that lot.
Ins??
Right now I can't be bothered remembering who's injured etc, let's just get as many games as we can into anyone who hasn't already had a go.
Get Daniher & Mosquito in. Yeah, they said Draper wasn't 100% ready but he did OK, so let's do the same for these 2.
And anyone else that isn't injured.
Just do it.

Just realised...9 Outs above and only 8 Ins.
So I'm adding Mutch to the Ins list.

Some players are so bad that just their absence from the team is like getting an extra player for us

[BenDoolan]

Out: T. Bellchambers, M. Gleeson, A. Francis, D. Zaharakis, T. Cutler, B. Ham, M. Redman, J. Stewart, J. Townsend

In: K. Langford, J. Daniher, D. Clarke, M. Guelfi, C. McKenna, S. McKernan, I. Mosquito, J. Begley

Agree with this. None of those "outs" are taking us anywhere. Should have kept Mitch Brown. People said he wasn't going to be in our next Premiership team, but jeebus he still earnt his spot before any of that lot.
Ins??
Right now I can't be bothered remembering who's injured etc, let's just get as many games as we can into anyone who hasn't already had a go.
Get Daniher & Mosquito in. Yeah, they said Draper wasn't 100% ready but he did OK, so let's do the same for these 2.
And anyone else that isn't injured.
Just do it.

Just realised...9 Outs above and only 8 Ins.
So I'm adding Mutch to the Ins list.

Some players are so bad that just their absence from the team is like getting an extra player for us

Haha

[Windy_Hill]

OK, so I have thought a little more about team selection and given the condensed playing schedule there will likely be the need to manage and rotate players through the selected 22


For this week I would go with


Townsend. Hurley. Zerk-Thatcher

Guelfi. Ridley. Saad

Redman. Shiel. Parish

McKenna McKernan. Walla

Snelling. Stewart. Mosquito


Draper, Merrett, McGrath

I/C. Begley, Francis, Clarke, Langford

In McKenna, McKernan, Mosquito, Begley, Clarke, Guelfi, Langford
Out. Bellchambers, Zaharakis, Ham, Cahill, Gleeson, Cutler, Smith


10 goal defeat incoming but at least we can try some new things.

I would like to see Townsend have a run as a defensive back pocket. Redman on a wing and McKenna in the forward half

[rockhole]

OK, so I have thought a little more about team selection and given the condensed playing schedule there will likely be the need to manage and rotate players through the selected 22


For this week I would go with


Townsend. Hurley. Zerk-Thatcher

Guelfi. Ridley. Saad

Redman. Shiel. Parish

McKenna McKernan. Walla

Snelling. Stewart. Mosquito


Draper, Merrett, McGrath

I/C. Begley, Francis, Clarke, Langford

In McKenna, McKernan, Mosquito, Begley, Clarke, Guelfi, Langford
Out. Bellchambers, Zaharakis, Ham, Cahill, Gleeson, Cutler, Smith


10 goal defeat incoming but at least we can try some new things.

I would like to see Townsend have a run as a defensive back pocket. Redman on a wing and McKenna in the forward half

Like your thinking, Windy I reckon Irish could go OK on the forward line on the basis that he could not do any worse than what was thrown up last Friday. I would also play Langford down forward as well.

[s'dreams]

Unlike most of the team last week - Smith actually gave a shit ... and you want to drop him?

[DC2]

Unlike most of the team last week - Smith actually gave a shit ... and you want to drop him?

not to mention he was pretty much the only player who could kick a goal.

mosquito cant even get a sniff in the scratch matches according to bounce, so why does he get a game?

[F111]

Smith hasn't had a great season so far. He was much better last game though, plus it's against his old team. Stays.