Wally copped a heap today on Facebook Tribunal Flashbacks,in '92.BenDoolan wrote: ↑Tue Mar 19, 2024 8:54 pmRemember the days when they suspended players (mainly Fletcher) for attempted tripping?nudder12 wrote: ↑Tue Mar 19, 2024 8:34 pmAgree totally.BenDoolan wrote: ↑Sun Mar 17, 2024 9:09 pmKicking (and even attempted kicking) is a dogs act. How they can possibly not get heavy handed on this is beyond me.s'dreams wrote: ↑Sun Mar 17, 2024 7:00 pm Redman has been offered a week for this.
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-ne ... ae2a9a0222
Soft but stupid.
Seems these days the rule is: Incident happens during play - careless. Incident happens off the play/during stoppage - intentional.
Now if someone can explain to me why Sicily kicking McGrath during a stoppage only gets one game.
Funny (not funny) thing though....I did a bit of googling for past kicking offences. And there's been a couple over the last few years or so, and all handed fines. Very surprising. When did that change from being one of THE worst crimes on a footy field?
2024 Round 2, EFC vs Syd-in-eeeee
Re: 2024 Round 2, EFC vs Syd-in-eeeee
Re: 2024 Round 2, EFC vs Syd-in-eeeee
The act of kicking another player, no matter what the circumstances, should be punishable with weeks.
Trying to soft pedal the act by calling it “low impact” or “minimal damage” attempts to diminish the dog act of kicking another player.
It makes a joke of Redmond’s weeks suspension for an open hand slap.
Trying to soft pedal the act by calling it “low impact” or “minimal damage” attempts to diminish the dog act of kicking another player.
It makes a joke of Redmond’s weeks suspension for an open hand slap.
Too far for Baker now he's on to it, now he’s got it, OPEN GOAL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! The Dons are in front by one point at the 8 minute mark
Re: 2024 Round 2, EFC vs Syd-in-eeeee
The act of kicking another player, no matter what the circumstances, should be punishable with weeks.
Trying to soft pedal the act by calling it “low impact” or “minimal damage” attempts to diminish the dog act of kicking another player.
It makes a joke of Redmond’s weeks suspension for an open hand slap.
Trying to soft pedal the act by calling it “low impact” or “minimal damage” attempts to diminish the dog act of kicking another player.
It makes a joke of Redmond’s weeks suspension for an open hand slap.
Too far for Baker now he's on to it, now he’s got it, OPEN GOAL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! The Dons are in front by one point at the 8 minute mark
Re: 2024 Round 2, EFC vs Syd-in-eeeee
I wouldn’t even call it a slap. Just an open hand push!rockhole wrote: ↑Wed Mar 20, 2024 10:41 am The act of kicking another player, no matter what the circumstances, should be punishable with weeks.
Trying to soft pedal the act by calling it “low impact” or “minimal damage” attempts to diminish the dog act of kicking another player.
It makes a joke of Redmond’s weeks suspension for an open hand slap.
Essendunny
Re: 2024 Round 2, EFC vs Syd-in-eeeee
Makes you question why the club didn't appeal Redman's penalty.
dices ad adepto futui (tell them to f*** off)
Re: 2024 Round 2, EFC vs Syd-in-eeeee
Sicily downgraded to a fine.
Re: 2024 Round 2, EFC vs Syd-in-eeeee
B:1. McGrath 32. McKay 21. Heppell
HB: 15. Laverde 29. Kelly 37. Martin
C: 5. Tsatas 6. Caldwell 28. Duursma
HF: 22. Durham 4. Langford 16. Perkins
F: 25. Stringer 20. Wright 11. Gresham
Foll: 17. Goldstein 12. Setterfield 7. Merrett (C)
Int: 2. Draper 3. Parish 13. Cox 19. Hind 47. Menzie
Emg: 8. Hobbs 23. Jones 33. A. Davey
Hobbs for Parish if ...
HB: 15. Laverde 29. Kelly 37. Martin
C: 5. Tsatas 6. Caldwell 28. Duursma
HF: 22. Durham 4. Langford 16. Perkins
F: 25. Stringer 20. Wright 11. Gresham
Foll: 17. Goldstein 12. Setterfield 7. Merrett (C)
Int: 2. Draper 3. Parish 13. Cox 19. Hind 47. Menzie
Emg: 8. Hobbs 23. Jones 33. A. Davey
Hobbs for Parish if ...
Re: 2024 Round 2, EFC vs Syd-in-eeeee
Good ins.
Probably reduces our loss by about 4 goals. So… what might have been a 12 goal loss, is now an 8 goal loss.
Probably reduces our loss by about 4 goals. So… what might have been a 12 goal loss, is now an 8 goal loss.
Essendunny
- Windy Hille
- Regular Senior Player
- Posts: 2001
- Joined: Fri Nov 25, 2011 7:49 pm
Re: 2024 Round 2, EFC vs Syd-in-eeeee
You might be onto something there F111. Parish on the bench is a question mark in itself.F111 wrote: ↑Thu Mar 21, 2024 5:24 pm B:1. McGrath 32. McKay 21. Heppell
HB: 15. Laverde 29. Kelly 37. Martin
C: 5. Tsatas 6. Caldwell 28. Duursma
HF: 22. Durham 4. Langford 16. Perkins
F: 25. Stringer 20. Wright 11. Gresham
Foll: 17. Goldstein 12. Setterfield 7. Merrett (C)
Int: 2. Draper 3. Parish 13. Cox 19. Hind 47. Menzie
Emg: 8. Hobbs 23. Jones 33. A. Davey
Hobbs for Parish if ...
If Pazza is 100% fit, you’d think he be plonked in the middle.
Time to stand your ground and beat them harbour hacky sacks.
Re: 2024 Round 2, EFC vs Syd-in-eeeee
Brad Scott addressed that during the week.
Says they got legal advice, looked at all possibilities, but there was no chance of winning at appeal.
Mostly because the rules state clearly that it's graded as "intentional".
Re: 2024 Round 2, EFC vs Syd-in-eeeee
That's fine,but were the Rules Clear or Fuzzy on Mr Kicker?
Re: 2024 Round 2, EFC vs Syd-in-eeeee
Confirmed. Hobbs in for Parish on bench.
dices ad adepto futui (tell them to f*** off)
Re: 2024 Round 2, EFC vs Syd-in-eeeee
We are having a crack. That’s a good thing.
Some players are doing very nicely a couple are as dodgey as all f***.
Hind and Heppell are are way too loose.
Some players are doing very nicely a couple are as dodgey as all f***.
Hind and Heppell are are way too loose.
Menzie!!
Things go awry without Jye!!
Regards
MH_Bomber
Re: 2024 Round 2, EFC vs Syd-in-eeeee
Nobody can fault effort tonight.
However pinpointing Targets needs to be seriously addressed...
Way too many turnovers.
Not Good enough at this Level.
However pinpointing Targets needs to be seriously addressed...
Way too many turnovers.
Not Good enough at this Level.
Re: 2024 Round 2, EFC vs Syd-in-eeeee
Effort?
f*** we are easily pleased
36 scoring shots to 26
19 marks inside 50 to 9
Please…
f*** we are easily pleased
36 scoring shots to 26
19 marks inside 50 to 9
Please…
Essendunny
Re: 2024 Round 2, EFC vs Syd-in-eeeee
Only caught the end on Channel 9 Skeapskate Radio,when AW's Perth link,plonked themselves somewhere in East Perth and called the action.What The F*ck was going on with that?
We got it back to 18,then coughed up 3 quick goals,like they toyed with us.
We got it back to 18,then coughed up 3 quick goals,like they toyed with us.