Page 1 of 3

Essendon Haters - Name and Shame

Posted: Tue May 26, 2009 3:13 pm
by Madden
There are so many threads on here about Essendon Haters TM in the media that I decided it was finally time for us to form the definitive list. To be added to the list, the person must be a well-known Essendon Hater TM - we all know who they are.

Please update this thread with your own additions and I will continue to update the list..

ESSENDON HATERS TM
MEDIA

Updated 29 May

Anderson, Jon
Bantick, Christopher
Bews, Andrew
Brereton, Dermott
Cometti, Dennis
Cornes, Graham
Dittmar, Chris
Dunstall, Jason
Fitzpatrick, Mike
Forrest, Leith
Healy, Gerard
Hutchison, Craig
Lane, Samantha
Lane, Tim
Lyon, Garry
Maher, Andrew
McGuire, Eddie
Morphett, Drew
Ralph, Jon
Rowe, Steven
Russell, Dwayne
Smith, Patrick
Taylor, Brian
Walls, Robert
Whateley, Gerard

Feel free to add your own... (with proof if necessary) - I will update this list at my discretion....

Re: Essendon Haters - Name and Shame

Posted: Tue May 26, 2009 4:24 pm
by ealesy
Drew Morphett- haven't heard him in a while, but when he used to commentate on Channel 7, he made his loathing for the red and black pretty damn obvious.

Re: Essendon Haters - Name and Shame

Posted: Tue May 26, 2009 4:42 pm
by Gatsid
Who was the moron that gave Dane Swan 3 anzac medal votes and Paddy none? Surely that bloke needs to go down just for that act of stupidity.

Re: Essendon Haters - Name and Shame

Posted: Tue May 26, 2009 4:45 pm
by Madden
Gatsid wrote:Who was the moron that gave Dane Swan 3 anzac medal votes and Paddy none? Surely that bloke needs to go down just for that act of stupidity.
Gerard Whateley. Good pick up.

Keep them coming people. We all bitch on about how everyone in the media hates us - so there should be lots and lots more that I haven't thought of...

Re: Essendon Haters - Name and Shame

Posted: Tue May 26, 2009 5:40 pm
by juff
Robert Walls

... daylight ...

the rest of the dudes on your list

Maybe Staggy you can also make a 'hall of infamy' list for those especially perverse Essendon haters like the bearded clam ....

Re: Essendon Haters - Name and Shame

Posted: Tue May 26, 2009 6:00 pm
by robrulz5
D.Brereton

Re: Essendon Haters - Name and Shame

Posted: Tue May 26, 2009 6:55 pm
by BenDoolan
Media:
Patrick Smith
Christopher Bantick

Onfield:
Matthew Nicholls
Scott McLaren
Ray Chamberlain
Michael Vozzo
Hayden Kennedy
Stuart Wenn
Shane McInerney
Stefan Grun
Stephen McBurney
Chris Donlon

Re: Essendon Haters - Name and Shame

Posted: Tue May 26, 2009 9:33 pm
by Madden
BenDoolan wrote:Media:
Patrick Smith
Christopher Bantick
I wasn't going to include Patrick, doesn't he barrack for us? Surely he is more of an Sheedy hater than an Essendon hater...

Christopher Bantick is a good pick up.

Re: Essendon Haters - Name and Shame

Posted: Tue May 26, 2009 9:57 pm
by BenDoolan
Staggy wrote:
BenDoolan wrote:Media:
Patrick Smith
Christopher Bantick
I wasn't going to include Patrick, doesn't he barrack for us? Surely he is more of an Sheedy hater than an Essendon hater...

Christopher Bantick is a good pick up.
Yeah, I wasn't sure about Patrick Smith. But Patrick Smith isn't sure what he is either. He hated Sheedy, then lambasted the club for not renewing his contract. In fact, he became obsessed with the events of Sheedy's departure that he re-hashed about 25 articles on the same topic with the same venomous criticisms. He then tried to discredit Knights as an appointee with a series of degrading comments....and even ran an article this year suggesting that some senior players are unhappy with Knights. He's been a shitstirrer of the highest order, and I wouldn't be surprised if he were behind the saveessendon.com mob. Does he really barrack for us? He's got a funny way of showing it :wink:

Re: Essendon Haters - Name and Shame

Posted: Tue May 26, 2009 10:15 pm
by jimmyc1985
Eddie McGuire, although i'm not sure whether he counts. His hates all the other 15 clubs and has an infantile fetish with Collingwood that fogs his mind.

Re: Essendon Haters - Name and Shame

Posted: Tue May 26, 2009 10:44 pm
by F111
Does Derek Kickett warrant a mention, or is that just a Sheedy thing?

Re: Essendon Haters - Name and Shame

Posted: Wed May 27, 2009 1:04 am
by grassy1
How about David Schwarze?He still Hurts from the BIG ONE in 2000 and STILL BANGS ON about Alternate Guernseys.Anyone who CRAPS ON about that in the Media is an ENEMY of the DAL,...BOMBERS and MUST BE EXTERMINATED! 8) :lol:

Re: Essendon Haters - Name and Shame

Posted: Wed May 27, 2009 10:14 am
by Scott
Guy sitting next to me on Saturday night. An Essendon Member who did nothing but bag the club and players the whole night and I quote!

"I pay good money to be a member and this is the rubbish you dish up"

End Quote.

Even when we started smashing them, he wouldn't let up....Finally I and the people around me told him to get his money back and stay at home FFS!!!!!

He left as soon as the siren sounded. I wish I knew his name.

Re: Essendon Haters - Name and Shame

Posted: Wed May 27, 2009 10:35 am
by Madden
grassy1 wrote:How about David Schwarze?He still Hurts from the BIG ONE in 2000 and STILL BANGS ON about Alternate Guernseys.Anyone who CRAPS ON about that in the Media is an ENEMY of the DAL,...BOMBERS and MUST BE EXTERMINATED! 8) :lol:
Schwartz would probably be one of the biggest Essendon lovers in the media I reckon. He talks us up given any opportunity.

Re: Essendon Haters - Name and Shame

Posted: Wed May 27, 2009 12:05 pm
by tonysoprano
Cometti - despite the fact his son barracks for the Bombers - he always demonstrates his insidious support for anyone playing against us, as well as undermining any victory we have by saying how "off their game" our opponents were. He even had the gall to write off our famous comeback against North in 2001 as "not really that special". f*** head.

Re: Essendon Haters - Name and Shame

Posted: Wed May 27, 2009 1:07 pm
by auditor
From South Australia

Graham Cornes ( Still bitter after what we did to him and the Crows in 93 )
Steven Rowe ( Former crow and now biased commentator ........)
Leith Forest ( Carlscum follower who continues to whing about Essendon's salery cap issues of the past )
Chris Dittmar( Port Adelaide follower who just hates Essendon )

Re: Essendon Haters - Name and Shame

Posted: Wed May 27, 2009 1:31 pm
by Crazyman
I am surprised that noone has mentioned adolf anderson or the MRP... :twisted:

Re: Essendon Haters - Name and Shame

Posted: Wed May 27, 2009 2:46 pm
by Doctor Fish
Blimey. Maybe we should name the Essendon Lovers instead. This list is getting horribly long...

Don't forget good ol' Alistair Lynch up in Brissy. Some very even commentary whenever we play up there...

:roll:

Re: Essendon Haters - Name and Shame

Posted: Wed May 27, 2009 2:49 pm
by Sismis
I'm guessing there would be roughly 15/16 people who follow football who dislike us to some degree.....

Re: Essendon Haters - Name and Shame

Posted: Wed May 27, 2009 6:54 pm
by BenDoolan
In days gone by Gerard Healy couldn't contain his dislike for Essendon in his commentary. The main reason being was the tagging jobs we used to employ on his buddy Greg Williams. He would ALWAYS highlight "unfair" (his words) tactics by firstly Shane Heard and then later by Sean Denham. And you could always hear the disappointment in his voice whenever we received a free kick or looked like taking control of a match. Suck eggs, prick.